Ynet: “Still Dreaming of Israelis and Palestinians Living Together”

Translated from the Hebrew original by Rann Bar-On.

“As a doctor, a mother and a human being I have always been strongly against any attacks on civilians, Israelis or Palestinian. But here we are serving as target practice for an organized army. The people are hungry, there is no water, electricity or communications, it is impossible to move freely on the roads and medical supplies are almost exhausted.” Mona El’Fara, a doctor in the Al Wada hospital in Jabalia, describes life in Gaza. A monologue and pictures from the other side of the checkpoint.

by Tamar Dressler, November 10th

“My name is Mona Al’Fara, I am 52 years old, a mother to three children, the youngest of whom is 14. I am a doctor in the Al Wada hospital in the Jabalia refugee camp in Gaza. I work for the Medical Committees Organization that operates the hospital, a number of other health centers and community health programs for children, women and teens. I serve as the health and development advisor for the organization and also co-ordinate projects for the ‘Chidren’s Union of the Middle-East’ in the Gaza area.

“This week, as I made my way to the hospital along the abandoned road, I could see Israeli tanks. The Al Wada hospital is not far from Beit Hanoun, and every day on my drive to and from work I felt fear. I fear that the Israeli army’s shells will hit the car in front of me or behind me.

“The general mood in Gaza is of a lack of security, but I still continue my work. I send my daughter to school and wonder if she will return home safe and well. Many children have been killed in the schoolyard or on their way to it. The Israeli army hits civilians during its operations, and sometimes we feel that the army intends to hit as many civilians as possible.

“It is difficult for me to travel freely throughout the Gaza Strip because I am very scared of missile attacks. I almost never visit my mother, certainly not as often as I should. I have no social life whatsoever and no possibility of planning ahead. From a mental point of view, things are very hard for me. I have mood swings, I feel depression and a deep sadness. I have trouble sleeping at night and terrible nightmares. My feelings are typical of almost all Gazans, even children and infants. The worst feeling is of being jailed – the borders are all closed, they have opened only six times in the last four months.”

* * *

“Last Sunday two rescue workers were killed as they were working, and one of the team members in the hospital was also hurt. On Monday at 7:30am a bus of 3-5 year old children arrived at the hospital. Their teacher was hurt by a falling shell and the bus evacuated her to the hospital. The youngest children were in shock. They were crying and shaking, and the team worked to calm them down. Some of the people burst into tears at the sight of the stunned children who were admitted to various departments.

“Two days ago I arrived at work exactly as the dead and wounded from Beit Hanoun began to arrive. Among the injured were those who were severely wounded and many children, it was without doubt one of the hardest days I’ve had in the hospital. The family members waiting outside were clearly traumatized. The triage room was crowded and we could barely function.

“Since the beginning of the operation in Beit Hanoun nine women from the town came to give birth at the hospital. They were made to wait for hours until they got permission to leave Beit Hanoun. Some of them stayed in the hospital because they couldn’t get back home, others found shelter with local families. With the help of the UN I managed to send 400 packs of baby formula to Beit Hanoun. I was told there was a great shortage of milk there.

“My feeling is that the terrible situation could have been prevented by the army. Saying “sorry, we apologize” is not enough. It certainly won’t bring the dead back to life.

“As a doctor, a mother and a human being I have always been strongly against any attacks on civilians, Israelis or Palestinian. But here in Gaza we are serving as target practice for an organized army. State terror is what I call it.

“For the past four months we have been living without electricity after the power station in Gaza was destroyed by a targeted bombing. The shortage of electricity makes life here very difficult. In the hospital we use a generator that uses expensive petrol. Since the border to Gaza is closed most of the time and it is impossible to transfer patients, the teams here are under enormous pressure, especially the surgical teams. We are forced to postpone almost every surgery that isn’t an emergency or life-saving so that we can conserve electricity for critical surgeries.

“Cancer patients are forced to give up chemotherapy and radiology treatments because they are not permitted to cross the Egyptian border. Patients in intensive care units are in dire states due to the shortage in the electricity supply. So are dialysis patients.

“At the moment, we still have medicine and other medical supplies, but we are fearful that they will soon run out completely. Despite the enormous pressure we are trying to ensure availability of supplies. Due to the situation, the operating expenses of the hospital have gone up enormously. Additionally, we are forced to treat most patients at no charge due to their financial circumstances. Around 70% of Gazans rely on international aid for a living.

“As part of our work, we found out that 42% of women and children suffer from severe anemia due to a shortage of iron. There is no doubt that this is caused by malnutrition and the lack of meat. That is the extent of the crumbling economy that is caused by sanctions and the siege.”

* * *

“The people of Beit Hanoun are hungry. They have no water, electricity or access to communications. Large tracts of agricultural land have been destroyed, medical teams are not permitted entry except in emergency cases and after complex co-ordination. The huge number of dead in the civilian population adds to the enormous pressure the fragile and diluted medical system in Gaza is under.

“The fact that Israel persists in carrying out the operation causes me sometimes to think that it does not seriously want to achieve peace and stability in the region. I feel that your government is trying to cause us, the Palestinians, to shrink to a minimum our national ambitions – until, in time, our attention will be diverted to the humanitarian situation and nothing else.

“I believe that the Occupation has to end, and that a peace process that is not based on justice cannot sustain itself. But peace cannot be dictated by the stronger side. I still dream of the day the war will end, then Israelis and Palestinians will live side by side in this ancient land.”

Dr. Mona Al’Fara requested that her picture not be shown.

CNN editors pull Palestinian quotes, replace with US

by cnnexposed.com

CNN editors replaced all Palestinian quotations with quotes from the US and Israel in its story ‘U.S. vetoes U.N. condemnation of Israel’s Gaza strikes’. The new, more prominent article begins with the exact same wording as the original, but all Palestinian remarks are gone.

The two versions have identical first and second paragraphs:

———-
UNITED NATIONS (CNN) — The United States vetoed a U.N. Security Council resolution Saturday that would have condemned Israel for its military operations in Gaza.

U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John Bolton said the resolution, which also called for Israel to immediately cease military operations in the Palestinian territory, was “biased against Israel and politically motivated.”
———-

The original wire followed with:

———-
The U.S. veto angered Hamas government spokesman Ghazi Hamad, who called the veto “shameful” and “not the first time” the United States has used a veto “just to protect Israel.”

The veto, Hamad said, is to “give Israel covering in order to continue its massacres and killings among our people. It is giving legitimacy to Israel to continue the aggression against our people.”
———-

But CNN editors pulled these two paragraphs, replacing them with a description of the resolution and vote tally, followed by a quotation from the Israeli military. It ended with five paragraphs quoting US Ambassador to the UN, John Bolton.

CNN neglected well-known journalistic standards when it removed Palestinian statements from its original report. According to Wikipedia.org’s Journalism entry, journalists must use “multiple original sources of information, especially if the subject of the report is controversial” and must “report every side of a story possible”.

CNN took an unethical step backwards when it morphed the responsible 4:37AM wire into a biased Sunday afternoon article.

Full text of the original wire:
———-
UNITED NATIONS (CNN) — The United States vetoed a U.N. Security Council resolution Saturday that would have condemned Israel for its military operations in Gaza.

U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John Bolton said the resolution, which also called for Israel to immediately cease military operations in the Palestinian territory, was “biased against Israel and politically motivated.”

The U.S. veto angered Hamas government spokesman Ghazi Hamad, who called the veto “shameful” and “not the first time” the United States has used a veto “just to protect Israel.”

The veto, Hamad said, is to “give Israel covering in order to continue its massacres and killings among our people. It is giving legitimacy to Israel to continue the aggression against our people.”

The resolution, proposed by the Qatar delegation, particularly condemned Israel for Wednesday’s shelling in the northern Gaza town of Beit Hanoun that killed 18 people, mostly women and children.

The proposal also condemns Palestinians who fire missiles from Gaza into Israel. (Posted 4:37 a.m.)
———-

Full text of the edited article:
———-
POSTED: 2:21 p.m. EST, November 11, 2006
UNITED NATIONS (CNN) — The United States vetoed a U.N. Security Council resolution Saturday that would have condemned Israel for its military operations in Gaza.

U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. John Bolton said the resolution, which also called for Israel to cease military operations immediately in the Palestinian territory, was “biased against Israel and politically motivated.”

Qatar proposed the motion, which focused on Wednesday’s shelling in the northern Gaza town of Beit Hanoun that killed 18 people, mostly women and children. (Watch mourners carry bodies of victims through the streets — 1:49)

The blocked resolution also condemned Palestinians who fire missiles from Gaza into Israel.

Israel’s military said it has been targeting militants in Beit Hanoun who have been firing Qassam rockets into Israel, and blamed a “technical failure” for the misfire that killed the 18 civilians.

The United States cast the only vote against. Four council members abstained and 10 voted for the resolution.

Before the vote, Bolton said the United States joined the other countries in “deeply regretting” the injuries and loss of life in Wednesday’s shelling, but said Israel has promised a full investigation.

Bolton said the resolution’s text was “unbalanced.”

“We are disturbed at the language of the resolution that is in many places biased against Israel and politically motivated,” Bolton said. “Such language does not further the cause of peace and its unacceptability to the United States in previous resolutions is well known.”

Bolton said the text was wrong in equating what he called Israel’s legal defense operations in Gaza with Palestinian acts of terrorism against civilians in Israel.

“We are disturbed that there is not a single reference to terrorism in the proposed resolution, nor any condemnation of the Hamas leadership’s statement that Palestinians should resume terror attacks on a broad scale, or calls by the military wing of Hamas to Muslims worldwide to strike American targets and interests,” he said.
———-

Full CNN Story

Take action against Israeli war crimes in Gaza

by ISM media team, November 11th

Since the Israeli “redeployment” from Gaza on August 20, 2005, Israeli occupation troops have killed over 700 Palestinians and wounded four thousand others. Israeli is literally starving the Gaza strip. Israel has also taken advantage of the western media’s preoccupation with the US midterm elections to commit new war crimes including large scale home demolitions, indiscriminate firing on peaceful demonstrators and the massacre of civilians in their beds. The atrocities of the last few days could intensify unless we focus attention on them and insist they be exposed by the media and stopped immediately. Palestinians have also called for an international week of action against the Apartheid Wall, and against the ghettoization of Palestine for November 9-16: http://stopthewall.org/worldwideactivism/1328.shtml.

Please write about this subject to all national and local media outlets as well as to all elected officials (including newly elected officials). The following two links are lists of media contacts:

Background information to use in your letters/communications:

Electronic Intifada reports on the massacres in Beit Hannoun:

People across the world are taking action against the atrocities in Gaza and the Apartheid Wall.

In London there was a protest on Thursday evening at the Prime Minister’s home at the UK government’s silence. A protest was held in the centre of the Norwegian capital, Oslo, on Friday evening and other protests are planned worldwide this weekend. Today, a joint Israeli-Palestinian protest is taking place at the Erez checkpoint into Gaza.

To kick off the international week against the Apartheid Wall, the Melbourne Palestine Solidarity Network erected a 3 metre-high wall in the centre of Melbourne containing photos and information about the Wall: http://stopthewall.org/worldwideactivism/1334.shtml

For more about events taking place worldwide visit:
http://stopthewall.org/worldwideactivism/1332.shtml

Take action against the Gaza atrocities at Israeli embassies, consulates and other institutions supporting Israeli brutality, and join the events taking place worldwide against the Apartheid Wall.

“It was very painful to see children dead on the street” — a Doctor’s account of Israeli massacre in Gaza


Photo by Dr. Mona El-Farra, November 8th

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

From ISM Media team interview with Dr. Mona El-Farra, a Gazan doctor working at Alawda Hospital in Jabalia:

“This morning at 6.30 am army tanks on the east of the village fired missiles against some homes of Beit Hanoun Village, the outcome was disasterous, 11 members of one family were killed, the total death toll is 22, and may increase in the next hours, the injuries are serious and very critical, including many women and children.”

“It was very painful to see young children dead on the street, most were badly injured. The Israeli army said they will investigate and open a case of what happened. But only 30 minutes after they declared that, a 16 years old Palestinian boy was shot dead by an Israeli sniper.”

English-speaking media contacts in Gaza:

Dr Mona Elfaraa, Doctor at Al Awda Hospital in Beit Hanoun.
Tel: +972 599 410 741 and +970 82846602
fromgaza.blogspot.com

Dr Abu Ala’a, Professor at Gaza University.
Tel: + 972 599441766

Dr Asad A. Shark, Gaza Strip, + 972 599 322636

Dr Ayoub Othman, + 972 599 412 826

Yousef Alhelou, Journalist based in Beit Hanoun.
Tel: + 972599697254.
Email: ydamadan@hotmail.com

The testimony of a young Palestinian in Beit Hanoun, Gaza: “They shoot at anything that moves”

The interview below describes events that took place nearly a week ago. Early this morning another massacre took place in Beit Hanoun. Eighteen Palestinians were killed instantly (7 of them children) and more have since died. Sixty people were lying injured on the ground, according to Palestinian doctors on the scene.

Interview conducted by Silvia Cattori, 3 November 2006

“Beit Hanoun, a town in the northern Gaza strip with 30,000 inhabitants, has been the target of daily aggressions and air strikes since June 25. It is now besieged by Israeli troops. We have seen the tanks advance and take up their positions. We are now encircled by about 70 tanks and at least 450 soldiers who announce that the city is a ‘closed military zone’. That means that no one can leave. No one can flee. It is an offensive modeled on those carried out in the West Bank in 2002.

“We have no water, no electricity. We hide in the remote corners of our houses. Ambulances are not authorized to enter into this occupied and closed zone. The soldiers have circled the houses they want to invade. They occupied the houses and they shut up the families in one room. Now they are using then as forts. They use explosives to pierce holes in the walls, they blow off doors, and the people are terrified. They shoot anyone that moves.

“Yesterday they fired on people that were seeking shelter, who were not armed, who were not in fighting positions. They shot them in the back, and when one was wounded and wanted to flee, they killed him. Those who wanted to collect his body were targets as well. In numerous cases, ambulances couldn’t go to the aid of the wounded. Children who slip out from their parent’s watch or that look out of the windows are killed by Israeli soldiers positioned on the roofs and balconies of the houses they occupy.

“They have the green light from Bush, and those politicians that affirm that Israel ‘has the right to defend itself, to kill us. They use arms that transform the dead and wounded into something monstrous. The wounds caused by the missiles launched from the drones are very impressive. They are like razor cuts; the legs, the feet, the hands all cleanly cut. They are as horrifying as wounds from an M-16. The soldiers have orders to shoot at the upper body. They aim at the chest, near the heart, the head.

“The victims are mostly civilians, killed or wounded in the throat, the neck, the chest, the head, even though they were in their houses. They shoot at people running in fear, who are trying to save themselves. We have lost any notion of time; we have no idea how long we have been caught in this war. We feel lost. There are planes that bomb us, drones ready to fire their missiles over our heads. They control the entire zone. With the sound of the drones, we always have the feeling of having a bee buzzing in our ears. It is really disturbing.

“There is no one to defend us. We don’t have an army. We have only our parents to defend us, knowing that they are going to their deaths and that they cannot defend us. This new aggression is horrible especially for the children who are very numerous here. They are forced to stay couped up inside, they are terrorized, and they cry when there are bombings. At any moment we can learn there are people killed, that there are people wounded who are bathed in their own blood, that people don’t know how to stop the hemorrhaging, and that the ambulances can’t give them any aid without being hampered.

“The Israelis say that they are waging this offensive to prevent the entry of arms from Egypt. That is false. Nothing can enter. In Gaza, there are only rifles that can do nothing against the Apache helicopters and the Merkava tanks of the Israeli army.

“Yesterday, through their loud speakers the soldiers demanded that all the young men fifteen years and older leave their houses. Then, sector by sector, they searched the houses and brought them out, handcuffed, and took them to a place where they certainly forced them to strip, as they did in Beit Lahia in June. They leave the men in their underwear. For an Arab, it is the worst of humiliations. They might as well kill us.

“We think that after Beit Hanoun they will attack Beit Lahia, and then Jabaliya and do what they have done here: search house by house. Beit Hanoun, like Rafah, is a very vulnerable zone because they are geographically separated from other inhabited areas. They are therefore easy to isolate from the rest of Gaza.

“This morning, the women went out to come to the aid of their sons or husbands threatened by the armored cars that encircled the Mosque. The women defied the Apaches and the armored vehicles. For us, it was a tremendous moment. We felt like we were wrapped up in a veil of humanity. It was very moving to see these women ready to die to save their sons and husbands. They continued on without hesitation, and the soldiers, who hadn’t expected this, were disoriented. Because of this effect of surprise, they succeeded, saving the lives of these fighters. They demonstrated that people with empty hands could defeat the largest army in the world. We took it as a message to the men of the Arab countries who remain silent. These women said, by their gesture, ‘There, in the face of your cowardice, Palestinian women by themselves are in the process of fighting for the release of their men who are besieged by the enemies of the Arabs, Israel.'”